“Sometimes you have to kill a mosquito with an axe.”
Mike Tomlin said this when talking about how a new coach needs to establish himself with his team. Tomlin, now an analyst with NBC Sports after a 19-year career as head coach of the Pittsburgh Steelers, was speaking about John Harbaugh’s tenure at his new team, the New York Giants. Harbaugh benched a running back for a fumble and cut another player for complaining about the offensive rhythm. Harbaugh, a Super Bowl-winning coach with the Baltimore Ravens, is in his first season with the Giants, and Tomlin noted that there is plenty of time to bond with players but only after you establish discipline, not because the coach is hard-nosed but because it is a way to hold the team accountable.
Writing in The Athletic, reporter Jayson Jenks noted that Tomlin’s comment is what Steeler players referred to as “Tomlin-isms”—sayings he used while coaching.
For generations, sports coaches adopted the persona of tough guys. Think Vince Lombardi.
Today that tough exterior works for a while, but it becomes tiresome and players tune out, especially now when elite players have options to play elsewhere. So coaches have a window to set expectations and the consequences of not meeting them. Good coaches like Harbaugh and Tomlin know how to hold players accountable while still showing them respect for their talent and skills. Lombardi, as tough as he was, spoke about how he loved his players, and while they may not have loved him in the heat of the moment, they respected him as their leader.
The lesson for managers is to set performance goals. Or as Tomlin would say, “The standard is the standard.” It is critical to hold people accountable, but it’s equally important to give them the resources they need to achieve their goals.
No need to wield an axe, but you do need to make it clear that doing things the right way is the best way to achieve the mission. “It’s not about what you’re capable of doing,” Tomlin would tell a rookie. “It’s about what you’re willing to do.”